For one worker dismissed in April 2024, justice is still more than two and a half years away. Labour specialist Tony Healy is handling that case now, and it is far from unusual. Across South Africa’s labour courts, judgment after judgment is sitting unfinished, and the people waiting on the outcomes are running out of time in ways the law never intended.
The scale of the problem is laid out in the Reserved Judgment Report for the Chief Justice at the start of Term 3/2026. Of the more than 2,100 matters across the legal system in which judgment has been reserved, 443 have been outstanding for longer than six months. South Africa’s four labour court divisions account for 184 of those, or 42%, a share that stands out even in a system-wide picture of delay.
The trend is moving in the wrong direction, and quickly. As Business Day reports, the number of delayed judgments has grown over the past few years and accelerated within the last year alone. In October 2025 the four divisions, in Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban and Gqeberha, carried 85 late judgments between them. By January 2026 that figure had climbed to 129, and by July it stood at 184. The backlog of cases before the Labour Court rose in step, from 163 in the preceding term to 184.
Behind those numbers sit budget pressures that Healy, CEO of specialised consultancy firm Icon Labour Consultants, describes in an interview with Stephen Grootes. The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and the bargaining councils carry their own backlogs, he says, compounding the waits workers and employers already face at the courts.
“You have these increased caseloads every year and then you have essentially a decreasing budget. So there’s not enough money to pay permanent or even part-time commissioners. And then on the other side of the scale, you have the delays in not as much in the CCMA and bargaining council awards, but when it comes to labor court judgments,” Healy says.
The staffing shortfall reaches the bench itself. The Labour Court is meant to have 13 judges, but vacancies are not being filled, according to Healy. The judges who are in place earn his clear praise. “I can tell you that those judges that are in place, are very, very good. The delay in the judgments is primarily when it comes to acting judges who are lawyers in private practice deployed to the labor courts for a week or two to hear cases.”
For the people these delays affect, the consequences are not abstract. Healy points to back pay as the sharpest example, particularly for employees seeking reinstatement after a dismissal. “Back pay is generally up to a maximum of 12 months in dismissal cases, although it can be up to 24 months in some. Therein lies one of the critical aspects which is the loss of back pay if you’re an employee who’s being reinstated - your back pay has a maximum of 12 months, but there may have been a delay in the judgment for longer than that period.”
In practical terms, a worker who wins the right to return to their job can see part of what they are owed simply expire while the judgment sits reserved. The wait itself costs money the law caps. Employers, meanwhile, remain in limbo over positions, payroll and planning while cases stretch on.
The picture that emerges from the report and Healy’s account is of a system strained from several directions at once: caseloads rising, budgets tightening, permanent commissioner posts unfilled, and a bench relying on short-term acting judges to keep hearings moving. For the workers and employers whose disputes sit in that queue, each month of delay carries a price of its own, and with no sign of new funding or filled posts, the worker dismissed in April 2024 may find the queue has grown longer still by the time a judgment arrives.